Photographer unknown: Police Aviation Force
Captain Charles N. Fitzgerald performing
a stunt, New York, 1920
Took me a while before I could even look at this one. Photographs of people endangering themselves at great heights are among the photographs that can give me such a strong visceral reaction that I can't look at them. Can't watch parkour videos, sorry. Free climbing, nope.
A few armchair experts have declared this to be Photoshop, but that probably just indicates the degree to which people's default now is to assume fakery. The trouble with that assumption is, there are old newspaper articles that include the picture and other views from the same outing:
And one writer even found a one-page bio in an old comic book!
The guy was apparently Knievel before Evel. (Evel Knievel, if you've never heard the name, was a motorcycle daredevil who did things like jump over canyons and multiple Greyhound buses 50 years ago.) Fitzgerald also did things like stand on the upper wing of a biplane as it did a loop-de-loop. He had 18 occupations in 26 years, most of which were dangerous. These included high diver, Texas Ranger, motorcycle racer, and vaudeville strongman. His status as Police Aviation Commander apparently came about because he talked the city of New York into giving him a biplane. He was that short-lived corps' one and only member. He subsequently fell out of the plane and spent a year in the hospital; further details, regrettably, appear lost to history.
According to the stories—which, I'll admit, do all sound a mite suspicious—his last adventure, like Evel's jump over the Grand Canyon, never came to pass. Evidently the rocket pioneer Robert H. Goddard, for whom Goddard Space Flight Center is named, once made an offhand comment about how hard it would be to hit the moon with a cannonball. Directly after which, dozens of people volunteered to get shot to the moon. The press wouldn't leave the story alone. The unwanted publicity and pesky questioning so exasperated Dr. Goddard that he became reticent with the press from there on out. However, our hero, Charles N. Fitzgerald, not only promptly volunteered to ride inside the cannonball (apparently assuming it was going to have to be a giant cannon), but went so far as to call it his "last adventure" and to formally say goodbye to his Mom!
I like the picture, anyway...now that I have steeled myself against my acrophobia and can look at it. I look at a lot of old pictures, one way and another.
Mike
(Thanks to Caramel and 1-900-Hotdog, among others)
Original contents copyright 2023 by Michael C. Johnston and/or the bylined author. All Rights Reserved. Links in this post may be to our affiliates; sales through affiliate links may benefit this site. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. (To see all the comments, click on the "Comments" link below or on the title of this post.)
Featured Comments from:
Herman Krieger: "Another girder, or rather a bridge crawler. This fellow was drunk, and crawled over the bridge on a dare from a drunken companion."
Bill Tyler: "Perhaps Fitzgerald and/or Goddard had been reading Verne's From the Earth to the Moon, in which the Baltimore Gun Club constructs and uses a giant cannon to carry three intrepid travelers on just that journey."
Tony McLean: "As a former rock climber, and having climbed a few routes on this limestone crag overlooking the town of Matlock, in Derbyshire, U.K., Paul Hill took this photograph of his daughter dangling her legs over the precipice. Here is an account of this famous image."
Mike replies: Probably Photoshopped. Just kidding!
It is a famous picture and it's a charming article. I very much like that series.
Gary Merken: "Wow, has it really been 50 years since Evel Knievel's heyday? Where'd the time go? I remember watching his motorcycle stunts on television when I was a kid. Jumping over the fountain at Caesar's Palace in Las Vegas. A line of buses at Wembley Stadium. A rocket-fueled attempt over the Snake River Canyon (I forget if he was successful in that one). Broke every bone in his body, twice.
"There was a hill with a narrow dirt path behind my elementary school. One day after school a group of us boys built a small ramp from a piece of wood and some logs and took turns riding our bicycles down the hill and over the ramp. My attempt didn't end so well; I crashed off the ramp and the handlebar dug into my stomach. No lasting damage, at least to my body. My pride, well, that was another story!"
The guy is obviously a daredevil with a high tolerance for risk. They've always been there throughout the years, like your Evil Knievel reference. I'm more impressed with every day Joes that may have all the natural protective aversions to risk, and have to endure them daily just for something as mundane as a paycheck.
I always like the photo linked:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunch_atop_a_Skyscraper
Posted by: Albert Smith | Wednesday, 08 November 2023 at 10:00 AM
Good to know that our press isn't going downhill, it was always terrible.
Posted by: robert e | Wednesday, 08 November 2023 at 12:02 PM
Two men meet in a bar and are getting to know each other…
One asks: “What do you do for a living?”
“I’m a human cannonball.”
“Really? How can you possibly make a living out of being a human cannonball?”
“It’s not a problem. I have lots of work and make plenty of money.”
“How can that be? I don’t understand.”
“It’s simple: I have plenty of work because it’s hard to find men of my caliber.”
[Not sure I should publish this...some things should not be encouraged! :-) --Mike]
Posted by: Max Cottrell | Wednesday, 08 November 2023 at 05:10 PM
Marc Riboud's "The Painter of the Eiffel Tower," Paris, France, 1953 can be mentioned in this company (a relatively rare vintage print of which came into my hands by a slightly quicky means by a dealer who didn't quite know what he was doing years ago when I didn't quite know what I was doing either.)
Posted by: calvin amari | Wednesday, 08 November 2023 at 06:43 PM
This reminded me of a story about overcoming a fear of heights to get the shot. I don't think I'd be able to do it however good the shot! https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2022/apr/27/steeplejack-break-chimney-salford-daniel-meadows-best-photograph-peter-tatham
Posted by: Michael Stevens | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 02:40 AM
In a similar vein and with a photographic connection is the film of Alex Honnold making a free solo (no, zero safety equipment) climb of El Capitan, in Yosemite. A sheer cliff face previously photographed by Ansel Adams.
Haven’t seen the film for years, but what I found most interesting were the emotional dynamics between Honnold and those who cared for him.
Posted by: John | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 04:47 AM
Had he focused on comedy instead of shooting for the moon, he might have been a Harold Lloyd or Buster Keaton.
Posted by: Sean | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 07:13 AM
That photo makes my feet go all tingly.
Scepticism can be justified - after all, that famous sequence with Harold Lloyd and the clock was faked.
Posted by: Timothy Auger | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 07:34 AM
Good story!
Ugh! These types of images always make me physically uncomfortable, too! Back when the “skyscraper” was new stunt images like this were not uncommon publicly-traps. Margaret Bourke-White’s Chrysler Building gargoyle image always gets me.
During the course of a project dealing with construction I captured several images that made my toes curl, even though I knew the subjects could not fall far.
https://www.kentanaka.com/tobuild#5
https://www.kentanaka.com/tobuild#6
https://www.kentanaka.com/tobuild#11
Posted by: Kenneth Tanaka | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 07:55 AM
Dear Mike,
are you aware of Austrian photographer and rock climber (or rock climber and photographer) Heinz Zak?
He took one the most iconic climbing photos: Wolfgang Güllich's free solo climb of Separate Reality in Yosemite Park. 19 years later, Heinz Zak made the second free solo of the route.
If you are interested, here are a few links:
Wikipedia article on Separate Reality (with a photo showing Heinz Zak): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separate_Reality_(climb)
Heinz Zak's Websit: https://www.heinzzak.com/datenschutz-01.html
Heinz Zak's climbing photos: https://www.heinzzak.com/kunstdrucke-05.html
Thank you for TOP. It's my favorite blog on the entire internet.
Thomas
Posted by: Thomas | Friday, 10 November 2023 at 09:25 AM