Open Mike: It Was Inevitable

Doing the test of the UHS-II card the other day I accidentally (or thoughtlessly) erased a card that was half full of new images from new shooting. Pictures I really wanted. And can't take again.

Augh.

In my early days with digital I inadvertently deleted one file that I really wanted. Fortunately I have a print of it, and still have the print. So the image isn't lost. (My son's first day of second grade.)

But I'm pretty sure that's the first time I ever deleted a card before downloading it. Is that kind of mistake just inevitable, or what?

Mike

Original contents copyright 2015 by Michael C. Johnston and/or the bylined author. All Rights Reserved. Links in this post may be to our affiliates; sales through affiliate links may benefit this site.

TOP's links!

(To see all the comments, click on the "Comments" link below.)
Featured Comments from:

Dick Drake: "I think you should be able to recover those images from the card with software."

Mike replies: I'm going to try that.

Carl: "Commercial shooting got me in the habit of having exact procedures, almost rituals, to failsafe equipment and film. For memory cards my rule is never to format a card until I've checked to see that the downloaded files have been backed up. Just downloaded isn't good enough. Also, this kind of mistake is most likely to happen when we're doing something different from our usual routines—something just like the write-speed test you were running."

Gordon: "My camera, a Nikon D750, comes with two card slots, and I have configured the second slot to capture duplicates of images stored on the first. When it comes time to delete images from the cards the camera requires me to delete from each slot separately, an added measure of protection. I have so far managed not to accidentally delete anything with previous cameras, but I am always concerned that a card may go bad so having the dupes gives me at least a little piece of mind. I try to take the same care, for similar reasons, with images transferred to disk...although I'd like to find a good and inexpensive cloud solution to that problem."

Henning: "Yes, it's inevitable. I've done it once, and that was a strong lesson that made me pay more attention. It's of course akin to all the ways that film could get ruined or the shots not recorded prior to getting put safely into a negative sleeve after development.

"Years ago, on the last day I saw my grandfather go out on his bike and shop at the local outdoor market, and talk to all the people I knew, I took a roll of film to document this, as I was going to go home the next day and likely not see him for a couple of years. After we left the market I realized that the film had not caught on the take up spool. I think that was the last time I made that mistake."

Stephen Gilbert: "Maybe everyone has to do it once, and you're good from now on."

Robert: "As has been mentioned, the way to prevent this is workflow. I use Downloader Pro for the download and for the deleting: the programme does not let you delete a file that has not been downloaded. The other essential part of the workflow is that I do not delete in camera. About formatting: formatting in camera only replaces the folder structure, something to remember if you ever want to get rid of a card."

Comments

[john]

Have you not tried some recovery software such as ImageRescue? When I formatted a full 32Gb card, I was able to recover all but a few pictures.

[David Dyer-Bennet]

Almost certainly recoverable if you noticed the problem before writing anything else to the card, you know; I think we've discussed various recovery software in the past.

[John Hall]

Don't write to it again and don't format it!
If you only erased it, chances are that a competent recovery software tool can find most of the images.
cheers,
john

[Carlos L. Esguerra]

You can still recover those images if you had not re-used the memory card and had written over the old files. Deleting does not necessarily erase the file. It only removes it from the table of contents. You can use recovery software or you can send the card to companies that recover deleted files such as Chrysler Camera Repair in New York.

[Tim Key]

There is an application on download.com called pandora which will bring most if not all back. Worth a try!

[Sandy Rothberg]

Rescue Pro (free when you buy SanDisk SD Cards)
or www.LC-TECH.COM/RESCUEPRO will recover those files almost no matter what you have done to the disk, formatted, erased whatever.

It has saved my bacon more than once

[Michael Korak]

Mike, I have no idea if the card you used would be able to re-generate some of you deleted images if a recovery program were used on it. On a few occasions in the past I was somewhat successful in recovering deleted files from cards using a few different apps. There were even applications that were included with the purchase of some memory cards back in the "old days". And yes, it is inevitable, just how often and how devastating is the incident after being once burned, or should I say UN-burned.

[Eric Brody]

Mike, don't despair, you can usually recover such files with recovery software from the card manufacturer. Sadly, I've done it more than once. What brand of card was it? Often the manufacturer includes a link to the software with the card, if not go to their website. Good luck.

[Roger Bradbury]

As inevitable as putting a roll of film through the camera twice. I've done that. It's only a matter of time before I do it with a memory card too, though I check before formatting.

[Hudson]

Try:

http://www.piriform.com/recuva

[Manuel]

It happened to me once, except that I only deleted one file. I wrote about the incident on my blog and one of the readers kindly suggested I used this:
http://www.cgsecurity.org/wiki/TestDisk
It worked. I retrieved the lost file. Don't know about the Mac, but the Windows version I tried is clunky and primitive. (It runs on MS-DOS!) Yet maybe it's worth giving it a try.

[David Fann]

Try Lexar's Image Rescue app before using that card again. You will probably retrieve most or all of the "deleted" images.

[jean-louis salvignol]

One day or another this kind of game inevitably induces a loss of contact with reality by becoming an end in itself. Remember the digital era, when we were opening the back of the camera without having rewound the film...

[Al DaValle]

Mike, I'm fairly certain you can use the caed manufacturers "rescue" software to retrieve the lost images. The images have likely not been erased....just the index file. I've done this before and had good luck recovering most of the images. Just don't use the card in the interim as this will write over the data you want to recover.

Al DaValle

[Josef]

This is why I consider dual card slots to be almost an essential feature for doing serious work. Maybe the X-Pro 2 will have them...

[wtlloyd]

You know the files are likely still on the card, right?
There are a number of card recovery utilities out there, just google them.

[Ken Ohrn]

Immediately sequester the card in a baggie. Don't use it again; don't write to it. Then get file retrieval software (there are several of these) and go to it.

Unless files have been overwritten, the files are still on the card.

[Richard Parkin]

File recovery software may help if you have not overwritten the images.

[Matthew]

I know that feeling, one of utter disbelief. I've successfully used a program called Recuva to actually recover deleted images from a card. My next camera will certainly be one with dual memory card slots.

[Rusty]

Sandisk offers a file recovery software "RescuePro", never used it but maybe of use to you?

[Geoff Morgan]

Might it be worth trying to recover the 'lost' images? I've found Photorescue very effective, but I'm sure there are many similar programs that could do the job (or at least attempt to).

[Herman]

It's just something in the cards.

[Dave Wilson]

If it's one of your SanDisk cards, try their Rescue Pro recovery software. http://www.sandisk.co.uk/products/memory-cards/sd/extremepro-sdxc-sdhc-uhs-ii/

[Howard Brunner]

I accidentally erased (re-formatted) a card once. In desperation, I downloaded a free trial version of a recovery software program. Much to my great surprise I was able to get those RAW files off of the "erased" card. It was free try software. You could view the results and determine if it was worth buying. It worked for my situation so I bought it and completed the recovery process.

[Ken White]

If you didn't format the card you might be able to recover. I believe the format is just FAT32. If so there are recovery tools that might be able to help. I'm sure any number of posters can will point you in the right direction.

[Rudolph Geesink]

As long as the card has not been used, the empty space is not overwritten and could be restored with the many utilities that exist for such as for example CardRescue that saved me under similar conditions. Works also after formatting as only the card database is erased and not the actual content.

[Andrew Kelley]

Mike, have you tried any of the various image recovery tools floating around the net? You may be able to save the files.

[Bob Blakley]

It's not inevitable, but it's likely if you don't have a workflow.

I've learned from video that this is the workflow. You have a little plastic box. The plastic box contains only cards which have pictures on them but which have also already been downloaded.

When you get a brand new card, you put it in the camera, format it, and shoot. Then you put it on the desk near the computer. When you get around to it, you download the pictures/footage. AFTER you download the card, you IMMEDIATELY put it in the little plastic box. When your camera needs a card, you take a card from the little plastic box, put it in the camera, and format it.

Cards NEVER go from the camera into the box. Cards NEVER go from the desk into the box. Cards ONLY go from the computer into the box.

Cards NEVER go from the computer into the camera. Cards NEVER go from the desk into the camera. Cards ONLY go from the box into the camera.

After you get used to this, it becomes automatic, and you never format a card before downloading it again.

[Gabe]

Can be recovered !
Don't do anything else with the card, go on line and download recovery tools from the card mfr., follow instructions closely and you'll (disclaimer) "usually" be fine.
Even when you format a card, the images are actually still there, and can usually be recovered. The recovery programs are remarkably effective ... So I guess, to answer your question, I have personal experience :).

[Bob Keefer]

Have you tried recovery software? I've retrieved images from cards even after formatting. Piriform's Recuva works really well -- it's easy and it's free.

[Markus]

Oh Mike, the joys of testing... I did that once (deleting, not testing), but as I recognized it before re-using the card, I could recover all files.

[R. Edelman]

I am sure that you know there is recovery software for deleted files, unless you wrote over the deleted files.

[Edward Taylor]

If you simply erased your card, then you can easily get those photos back with free recovery software. If you wrote over all your pictures during your test with new images, then you may be out of luck.

[Alan Klughammer]

The digital equivalent to opening the back of a camera with film still in it...

[DavidB]

There are a number of tools that will undelete images from a card -- as long as you have not overwritten them with new data.

I have used PhotoRec -- an OpenSource package that runs on many OS'es.

http://www.cgsecurity.org/wiki/PhotoRec

Good luck.

DavidB

[Greg]

Those photos should be recoverable if you havent' copied over them and if you didn't do a secure delete.

I haven't had to do this lately so am not up to date on how to do it, but Google should find the methods or apps. With a normal delete you've only deleted a reference to the file, not the file itself.

Good luck.

And you can edit out the following.

PS: You never publish my comments. And I've seen some that don't seem as relevant or good. Can you comment on why that it? Thanks for the great blog.

[Tom Judd]

If you have not shot anything else on that card, images that were "erased" should be recoverable. Look on line for recovery programs. Good luck!

[Bob Blakley]

By the way, I should have added that this is neither a new problem nor a digital problem; sheetfilm-holder darkslide tabs have one black side and one white side for exactly this reason. So every time you put a card into the little plastic box you can recite a Paternoster to Ansel :-)

[Stuart Hunter]

I'm sure you can retrieve the images (even if you've formatted the card) with retrieval software. I think as long you don't start shooting images on the card again they are still there. I remember a technician at a college I was teaching at being able to retrieve images from a formatted card.
Best regards
Stuart Hunter

[Francisco Cubas]

Mike, there are many tools to recover the data erased from a card or hard disk. Here's a link with a few of them: http://www.computerworld.com/article/2501547/data-storage-solutions-6-data-recovery-tools-for-sd-cards-usb-drives-and-more.html

[Mark Kinsman]

Don't shoot any more images on that card until you've tried to restore it. I've had extremely good luck using Sandisk's utility. Worth trying.
Mark

[Tom]

If it was only erased and not written over it could potentially be recovered with software.

Tom

[Peter Costantinidis]

How did you erase the card? I'm wondering why you couldn't use data recovery software to get the images back.

[Mikey]

If it's important enough though, there is software out there for recovering lost files, even from a formatted card, so long as you didn't start writing new data on it.

[Gordon Lewis]

You do know that thereare several image retrieval utilities you can use to recover your "deleted" images, right?

[Dickon Whitehead]

Ok but not the end of the world unless you have overwritten the files!

Try PhotoRescue or File Salvage (and many others probably) they work!

[Alex Monro]

Traditional photographic errors, my score:

Failing to fully engage film leader in take up spool, and failing to check rewind knob was turning - yup.

Opening camera back before fully rewinding film - yup.

Neglecting to back up before the hard disk crash - yup.

Putting the fixer in first - not yet.

Formatting card before uploading - not yet.

But I'm sure the last two are just a matter of time...

[Sherwood McLernon]

Don't take any more photos and you can retrieve them with free software from the card manufacturer

[GFK-B]

Yes; hence the number of file recovery programs available. They work sometimes (saved some important images of mine once!) if you haven't reused the card before running them.

[Pete Teoh]

Have you tried using card recovery software to try and get the images back? Usually when you "delete" a file the data is still there, just no longer on the table of files. If you haven't overwritten the space with something else, recovery software can often get the images back for you.

[Josh Hawkins]

Inevitable, preventable but inevitable. Good processes and procedures are the only way to reduce frequency but it happens. Analyze, adapt and move on in this case.

[Kenneth Tanaka]

Have you tried any recovery techniques on the erased card? There are free/near-free utilities that can perform feats of magic on memory cards, particularly if you have not recorded new material on the card.

[dennis]

a sure way to make no mistakes is to do nothing.

[Frank]

Hey, Mike before you do anything else download a free picture recovery software from Sandisk, works great. Good Luck

[Joe Holmes]

Is it too late to use one of the disk recovery apps, like RescuePro? (It is if you've written to the card, but not if you've only formatted it.)

I try to prevent accidentally doing what happened to you by rotating four cards, always loading a fresh card from the bottom of the pile each time I go out. It doesn't guarantee it won't make a mistake, but it does give me a little extra protection.

[Rick Grant]

There is a pretty good chance that you can recover those photos, if you haven't been using the card since you formatted it.

Look for a program called Recuva, but there are several others that can also undelete formatted cards and deleted photos.

[Patrick Perez]

Well, if you search the internet, you might find instructions on how to recover the files, if you haven't started writing to the card again yet.

Patrick

[John Hendry]

If you've used quick format then the data will still be there, the directory's gone. There are recovery programs around. Sandisk (I think) used to install a copy on their CF cards at one time.

[John Hendry]

... forgot to add that if you take another picture then the data gets overwritten.

[Karsten Schmidt-Hern]

Try RescuePro. I have used repeatedly when PhotoMechanic did funny things to my fuji xe-2 files. I had the impression that the program recovered files from before a reformatting of the card in camera.

[George Barr]

I found photo rescue to be very helpful with 'deleted' cards, sig. better than card branded software - worth a try.

George

http://www.datarescue.com/photorescue/v3/

[robert e]

Given the nature of the tests, I assume the data was overwritten, probably multiple times, and the card reformatted. And yet... did you check? There are a number of free recovery utilities out there. Couldn't hurt, aside from a little time.

I so empathize. I accidentally lost a ten minute interview once in a card shuffle with a cameraman.

[Bahi]

You'll get a ton of responses to this effect, I'm sure, but: you can rescue those images. The reformatting process just deletes removes the index but doesn't overwrite the pictures. So if you haven't rewritten to that card, you have a good chance of getting the pictures back. Even if you have, you're in with a good chance of recovering some or all of them. Try SanDisk's RescuePro – you should have received a serial code for it with your SanDisk card. Lexar ships something similar with its cards, called ImageRescue.

[Doug Nelson]

There are plenty of unerase/undelete programs out there. No guarantee, but they do work sometimes.

[Jim Meeks]

I just looked on CNET and there is an article about PhotoRec for Mac and they also mention other options if the disk is from Lexar or Sandisk. They mention you might be in trouble if you shot over the deleted images however. The good news is this piece of software is free.

[Andrew Gastwirth]

Mike,
there are numerous programs to restore deleted files on a card. If you have not overwritten them with other files you may be able to restore them.

good luck

AG

[Speed]

From BHPhoto ...

Recover Deleted Photos and Videos with RescuePRO Deluxe Software The 64GB Extreme PRO SDXC UHS-II memory card comes with an offer for a one-year subscription to RescuePRO Deluxe data recovery software. With RescuePRO Deluxe, it's easy to recover lost photos or videos and save them to your computer's hard drive even if they were deleted months ago.

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1030991-REG/sandisk_sdsdxpb_064g_a46_64gb_extreme_pro_sdxc_uhs_ii.html

[xfmj]

Mike,
Was the card "erased" or "reformatted"? I've recovered image files from a card that I accidentally erased. I can't remember the tool I used, and this was 5 years ago, but tools like it must still exist. I'll let others chime in.

I'm just hoping that you didn't take many pictures after erasing, in which case some (or maybe all) of the image data is still there. Set the card aside and find the kind of tool that I found.

[Peter Williams]

Mike, you should be able to recover the images if you haven't been writing to the card since.
There are a number of free undelete and unformat utilities that will find all the file fragments and re-index them to allow recovery.
http://kb.sandisk.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/4985/~/data-recovery-for-memory-cards-and-flash-drives

[Bob Bradley]

Mike,
I had a similar senior moment but recovered the files with a program called Recuva. It's $24.95 but may be worth it if the files are important. Here's a link to their home page:http://www.piriform.com/recuva

[John Hagen]

I have used Photo Rescue to deal with the same issue. It helps when you inadvertently format the wrong card, but not if you format the card and then shoot over it. Others may have different file rescue programs, I have only used Photo Rescue.

Did the UHS-II card delete faster?

[Dave Stewart]

If it was a Sandisk card of decent quality, you normally have (or had) a free one download option of their Rescue Pro Deluxe software, with a year's licence.

Have used this a couple of times, and most recently even with a card that had both been formatted in camera, and in a PC (after switching off the quick format option). It still recovered a load of images from last Summer! I'd only been after one that had been recently deleted in error.

If you didn't keep the wee bit of paper, I have a couple about here somewhere, and you can have one.

[B.J. Segel]

Mike,
You'll probably get a million responses to this. There is recovery software available. Ctein should be able to direct you to it. Sometimes it is included with the card when you buy it. You should be able to recover all or most of the pictures pictures, provided you haven't used the card again.

[Terry Gallant]

I am sure you are aware of software which will recover the files from the card.

I use "CardRecovery"

Will give you a series of Files renamed to "File####"

In case you forgot.

[Richard Jones]

I have a routine: upon arriving home after photographing, I immediately download the files on the card to the computer, then to a external backup. Not until I see the files display on the computer and the backup, do I format the card.

I have a number of such routines -- without them, something possibly will go wrong...

- Richard

[Tom Hassler]

Been there, it happens. Your SanDisk cards likely came with a free trial of RescuePro recovery software. Depending on how many times you have re-formatted the card, you can probably recover some (maybe all) of the lost pictures. Give it a try, highly recommended!

[Ken Bennett]

Sandisk cards come with a registration code for a rescue application, which works very well on formatted cards as long as you have not shot new images.

[Stephen F Faust]

It's very possible that you can recover some, most, or even all of the files from the card. First, you need to STOP using it - don't write more files to it, format it, or use it in any way. Assuming you were using the Sandisk card, you can download a copy of their Rescue Pro software (http://www.lc-tech.com/pc/sandisk-rescuepro-and-rescuepro-deluxe/) and let it work it's magic. Good luck!

[John Camp]

You wouldn't want to be the kind of guy in which an incident like this was not inevitable.

[Phil Cook]

Don't reuse it yet. Try file recovery software!

[Bryce Lee]

Digital, your son's second grade; is your son 'zander that young or is digital that old? Things never cease to amaze.

Now what would have happened if you had erased "a roll of film?"
Now that of itself would be news.

Sorry for your loss; done it myself, and I might add very easy to do. Solution form e is I number all of my digital cards from when I first purchased same (1 and 2 are both 512 mb) and ensure the lower placed numbers are erased and stored in their own little plastic zip-lock
baggies.

[Tony Collins]

They may be retrievable especially if you haven't formatted or over-written loads of new files.

[James]

Try downloading the free software photorec - it does a remarkable job at recovering images from a formatted card.

http://www.cgsecurity.org/wiki/PhotoRec

[Eric]

If you haven't used the card, you're in luck.

If you've used the card but haven't filled it completely with new pictures, you're partially in luck.

You can find software to recover deleted files on cards. The good news is that the cards have limited write capacity. After a while, they'll wear out and you'll be unable to use them. That "while" is defined as millions of write cycles, so chances are they won't expire in your lifetime. But if files were written to the cards in an unintelligent manner, they would expire sooner. Files are written to cards to try to give even usage to all the blocks. (That's the theory. Never perfect in practice.)

But what that means is that if you're card was half full, you formatted the card, and then filled the card up half again...you may be able to recover close to all the deleted files. Just stop using the card, and find recovery software.

Sandisk used to have offers of free limited use when you bought one of their cards. Otherwise, I'm sure you can find something...even for Macs. :) (All my experience is with Windows.)

Eric

[jim woodard]

Mike,
All of us-of a certain age at least, have opened the camera on a roll of exposed film. And the images on that roll are always some of your best. Like you and the shot of Zander in second grade I've never forgotten mine. Maybe that's a pretty priceless gift in itself?

[Eric]

Very bizarre. I looked at your article, and it said there were no comments. So I repeated what everybody else said. As soon as it posted my comment (complete with "you're" typo that I noticed after I hit post), then I saw the litany of other responses. :)

[Malcolm Myers]

As others have said, SanDisk Rescue Pro is your friend. I have saved several images with it, both RAW and JPEG.

[Matt]

Photorec is free, super effective, and faster than the commercial options I've used. If you haven't re-used the card, you should be able to get everything back.

[David Burren]

It happens to all of us. The smart thing is to use it as a learning experience. :)

As has been noted by a zillion others the RescuePro Deluxe software can be used, and you will have got a 1-year coupon with the SanDisk card. All their Extreme cards come with this, so like Dave Stewart I have a stack of these I can renew with every year.
However like George Barr for years I've been using PhotoRescue. Still works great!
However do note that with the 64 GB card the camera will be using the ExFAT filesystem instead of the older FAT32 filesystem (at 32 GB they usually use FAT) and some recovery software might not be able to handle this.

Actually I wrote up some notes on deletion/formatting and mentioned recovery only a few weeks ago: http://khromagery.com/2015/01/02/deleting-images-in-camera/

[Michel]

I don't have anything to add except to say that John Camp's comment made me laugh.

[MikeR]

I can't add anything that 40 other people haven't already said. But I can add this:

Unless you're just playing and don't care what's on it, why format a card at all? On a per-image basis, they're cheap as hell, far cheaper than film ever was. Slide the "lock" tab if it has one, mark it to identify & date it, and put it into a box, never to be re-used. It's the ultimate last ditch archive.

[Andrea Blum]

Given the number of folks who are suggesting various file recovery apps, the question becomes -- who out there has not accidentally deleted unstored images from a card?
The embarassment comes when one has performed such a delete blooper more than one time. I probably should not admit to that publicly.

[nicholas von staden]

My hats off to DataRescue's..Photo Rescue...used it for years in the newspaper bus.

[Mark]

I don't know if anyone has mentioned it yet, but you can get your pictures back with recovery software.

[Chuck Albertson]

Don McCullin lost two rolls of exposed Tri-X crawling out of the Battle of Hue in 1968, and he still thinks about those missing pictures to this day.

[Matthew Speicher]

+1 for PhotoRec

As someone who works in computer forensics, I am saddened that the ability to recover these files with free software is not common knowledge. I have heard the "I deleted my photos!" story months after the fact more times than I care to remember. Nowadays, if conversation moves towards my work, photography or anything remotely connected to the two, I try to tell them that deleted files aren't gone forever if you stop using the disk.

[Jack]

You have 99 comments on recovery of digital files.
In 1973 I needed comments on how to recover B&W negatives that I mistakenly developed as if they were color negatives. For those of you who never developed color negatives, there is a bleach step that unfortunately erases the silver in B&W negatives. You get a nice totally clear film. Difficult, no impossible to recover.

Never drank before going into the darkroom again.

[David L.]

reformatted is not a permanent mistake

photos are not lost in the card

don't fret, you'll get a lucky break

your files from working hard

recovered like a piece of cake

and next time be on your guard

[Mani Sitaraman]

Chuck, thanks for mentioning Don McCullin and that story.

The story of Robert Capa on D-Day may be more widely known, with the film dryer in the lab melting 95 of 106 pictures he took in the first hour of the landing. Good thing one of the remaining pictures was still iconic.

http://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2014/06/photographer-robert-capa-d-day

Mike, try to recover the files before you give up. Your situation is much better than Don McCullin's or Robert Capa's :)

[BH]

I did the low-tech version of this last summer with my M6: Took off the bottom plate before remembering to rewind the film.