« Hypothetical Question: What Would You Do? | Main | Random Excellence: Deborah Luster »

Friday, 11 October 2013

Comments

Same thing was said to me by an elderly Italian lady....

I don't want to be a spoilsport, but unless this woman has given permission to be identified he really shouldn't be telling anyone stories about her, however benign.

I hear that shtick all the time here in NYC, but the point is valid. Just because something is right for one person or their mother doesn't mean it's right for anyone else, so a recommendation based on "what would be good for my mother" doesn't mean a lot until you know something about said mother.

A couple years ago when I was in a gift store waiting for my wife there was another couple discussing what would be an appropriate gift for her mother and the man asked me what MY mother would like. My answer was that she wanted me to get her a plasma cutting torch ( she's a very young 80), but that might not be the thing for his mother in law.

Sort of like asking a photographer for a camera recommendation based on what they would most like if they had only camera. According to the hypothetical question posed yesterday, we would be advising either a Nikon d800, a large format film camera, or maybe a Leica S2.

BTW, my mother longs for a digital camera as easy to use as her old Argus C3, or Canon rangefinder but is delighted with the camera in the iPad mini we got for her to use as a radio substitute since she can't get NPR where she lives.

The comments to this entry are closed.